As organizations race to adopt artificial intelligence, leaders are urging—requiring, even—workers to use AI tools to get things done. What can the bots make or do for you today?
As a result, something troubling is happening to the way people approach communication. With so much focus on what AI can produce, we’re losing sight of what good communication looks and feels like, what it takes to make it happen, and what we stand to lose by relegating this important work to AI.
One reason clients engage my communication and creativity consultancy is to prepare leaders and subject matter experts for high-stakes presentations. The pitch to wavering customers. The report to wonky stakeholders. The vision for change to a weary workforce.
In these make-or-break moments, most organizations have the good sense to choose appropriate messengers. I’m privileged to work with intelligent, experienced professionals who have valuable knowledge to share. They are more than capable of engaging in informative and persuasive conversations.
These people know their sh*t.
They’re also busy. They’re swamped with competing priorities, performance goals, and ever-growing demands on their time.
So, when superiors mandate the use of AI, these high performers comply, hoping the tools will lighten their loads. Preparing for a presentation, they point an AI assistant at a folder containing an outline and supporting documents. The bot quickly produces a deck: slides, headings, bullet points, charts, images, and plenty of information. It even complies with brand standards. This thing sure looks like a presentation.
But look again.
The slides are cluttered and redundant. Minor details take center stage while major messages are buried or absent. Information abounds, but there’s no story, no heart, no reason for the audience to care.
Technically, AI has generated a presentation. But it hasn’t prepared the communicator for an effective conversation.
What concerns me isn’t just that AI produces bad work. It’s the risk that we’ll become willing to accept bad work as good enough.
When everyone does it, who will question it?
Organizations have invested heavily in AI tools. Leaders want to see a return on that investment, so AI adoption becomes a priority. Employees are encouraged—or explicitly required—to use these tools in their daily work.
The mandate is clear: Use AI. Be more productive. Prove that you’re advancing along with the technology.
But is there an equally clear expectation that the work must be good?
When people are stretched thin, they crave quick and easy wins. Evaluating and rethinking an AI-generated deliverable isn’t quick or easy. What a relief when the tool has done its job! The slides are finished. Another task is complete. Win!
And when everyone in an organization is producing similar decks, the output starts to look normal.
No one intentionally lowers the standards. No one proclaims that lackluster communication is okay now. We just slide downhill gradually, becoming accustomed to work that passes without scrutiny.
That’s how inferior work becomes normalized.
The emperor’s new clothes, corporate edition
Do you know the story of The Emperor’s New Clothes? It’s Hans Christian Andersen’s enduring fable about something oh-so-human: how easily we go along with absurd behavior rather than dare to be the one who questions it.
When everyone around us acts like something is good, smart, or impressive, it’s remarkably difficult to say otherwise.
AI makes this dynamic even trickier. Its work arrives quickly, in a form that looks polished, professional, and final. What’s more, because the technology is considered innovative, challenging its output may feel like resisting progress.
But a slick-looking deliverable isn’t necessarily a good one.
- A presentation can contain accurate information and still fail to communicate.
- A report can be comprehensive and still miss the point.
- A diagram can surface in seconds and still confuse the audience.
The appearance of completion is not the same as achieving a meaningful result.
As a third-party consultant, I often play the part of the child in Andersen’s fairy tale. I can raise my hand and point to what others have stopped noticing.
My objections don’t stem from resistance to AI (ChatGPT helped channel my thoughts into this article). Nor am I insisting on communication the way we did it in the good ol’ days.
I simply ask: Will this work serve its purpose?
We need more people willing to ask that question.
Crucial work happens before the deliverable
AI-generated work is bound to fall short when we confuse producing an artifact with doing the creative, strategic thinking required to make that artifact effective.
Think about what goes into a successful presentation.
Before anyone fires up PowerPoint, someone needs to understand the audience. What do these people already know? What do they need to understand? What questions are they asking? What might confuse them, persuade them, or change their minds?
Someone also needs to identify the big idea—the one thing we want the audience to take away. Of all the available information, what deserves attention, and what can we omit? What examples or metaphors will illustrate our points? What’s the story that will connect the details into something meaningful and memorable?
This work calls for human intelligence. It takes judgment, creativity, and empathy for the people we’re trying to reach.
AI can support this process. It can help organize information, suggest alternatives, and speed up production. Used thoughtfully, it can be a valuable partner.
But prompting AI to produce a deck from an outline and a handful of documents doesn’t guarantee that anyone has done the essential work of communicating. A human being must decide what the material means, why it matters, and how to make it meaningful to a particular audience.
Communication isn’t the act of putting information in front of people. It’s the work of connecting with people so they see what you see—and maybe even do what you hope they will do.
That distinction is easy to lose when you’re focused on speed, volume, and tangible output.
What happens when we stop exercising our expertise?
There’s another potential cost of letting AI handle communication work: When we delegate the thinking as well as the production, we risk weakening the very capabilities that make us effective and valuable in the workplace.
Creative thinking improves with practice. So does the ability to structure an argument, tell a compelling story, distinguish essential information from extraneous detail, and anticipate an audience’s response.
These skills don’t develop simply because we have access to sophisticated tools. They develop when we use them.
If we routinely allow AI to make the first—or, heaven forbid, final—decisions about how to organize ideas, we risk losing the confidence and muscle memory to do that work ourselves. We become less accustomed to questioning the obvious, exploring alternatives, and noticing when a seemingly reasonable message misses the mark.
Ready for the irony? In our efforts to become more valuable today (productive), we may neglect the uniquely human capabilities that make us valuable tomorrow (indispensable).
That’s worrisome for individuals, but organizations should be concerned, too. Can AI help employees get more done today? Perhaps. But how much intellectual power are we draining from the workforce of tomorrow?
We need higher, not lower expectations
I’m not asking you to reject AI or insist that people do everything the analog way.
I am suggesting that we become more discerning about the work we ask AI to do, the decisions we delegate, and the standards we apply to the results.
Communicators: Resist the temptation to treat an AI-generated deliverable as a finished product. Examine it. Challenge it. Restructure it. Apply your expertise. Ask whether it will serve the people who read it, hear it, or use it.
Leaders: Look beyond AI adoption rates and productivity claims. Are presentations changing minds and generating sales? Are reports supporting better decisions? Are people building fruitful relationships?
If your organization is producing more content but communicating no more effectively—or perhaps less effectively—something is wrong.
Everyone: Remember that good work requires standards, judgment, and accountability. The fact that a tool can generate content quickly doesn’t mean that content deserves to be part of the conversation.
The human advantage won’t go away
As content generation gets easier and faster, the ability to exercise sound judgment about that content becomes more important, not less.
When information abounds, discernment cuts clutter. When production is cheap, originality and relevance stand out. When everyone has access to tools that generate plausible first drafts, the ability to see what’s missing—and make the result genuinely effective—becomes a differentiator.
This is where creativity and communication expertise matter: turning information into insight, making complex ideas understandable without dumbing them down, crafting stories that illustrate why something matters, and connecting with an audience rather than merely filling its field of vision with information.
This is the work of communication.
AI can help us do the work. Or it can help us avoid it. The difference rests in how we use the technology, the questions we ask, and the standards we refuse to abandon.
Next time an AI tool spits out a presentation for you, resist the urge to congratulate yourself simply because the deliverable exists. Instead, ask:
Will this deliverable result in good communication?
And then do the human thinking required to make sure the answer is yes.
